Watch This Movie
Download This Movie
Alternative downloads
Ben Stein’s Debate for Intelligent Design Lacks Substantial Argument
Dec 17, 2008 Rob Humanick
Ben Stein may be a certifiable genius, but his (in)ability to sufficiently craft an argument is so deprived that any rational person could be forgiven for mistaking him as outrightly deranged. His cinematic thesis, Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed, plays so poorly and laughably that one may very well mistake it for a lampoon of its subject matter (here, the debate between evolution and Intelligent Design).
Expelled is Short on Insight; Long on Assumption
Sadly, no such irony exists here. Expelled’s argument for ID is so dimly and laughably constructed that anyone who isn’t familiar with the topic could easily become overwhelmed – strike that – infuriated by the rampant assumptions and finger-pointing abundant therein. A disingenuous bit of propaganda masking itself as an informed and evenhanded documentary, Expelled makes one valid point before stepping permanently outside the lines of acceptability, that being that, despite its overwhelming popularity within the scientific community and the culture at large, Darwinian theory is incomplete insofar as it answers how life arose in the first place.
From this moment on, the film assumes that this lack of conclusive evidence on the part of the scientific community represents nothing less than proof of Intelligent Design. Period. End of discussion. Not for a moment does Stein even attempt to provide his own shreds of evidence, let alone an encompassing argument that could claim some sort of irrefutable proof. That this double-standard bias violates virtually every rule of rational debate (i.e. lack of evidence for one argument does not inherently render a sufficient counter-argument) makes it difficult to accept anything else that the film proceeds to establish is a given, and one made even more frustrating given Stein’s supposed dedication to scientific inquiry.
Science vs. Religion vs. Science & Religion
For him, ID needn’t be a religiously associated belief, but instead represents a viable scientific acknowledgment that entities beyond our understanding or perception may very well exist in the universe, and that such entities may have deliberately planned and created life as we know it. Call it God, call it the Big Bang, call it the unseen aliens that nurture mankind from across the cosmos in 2001: A Space Odyssey: the fact remains that, as to how life itself arose, we don’t know. It’s an essential truth and one that addresses the fundamental relationship between science and religion, but it’s one only appreciated between the lines in this rancid debacle of a film. Indeed, to grant Expelled any credibility beyond the opening minutes requires nothing short of a leap of faith.
Offensive Documentary Tactics
Stein interviews scientists both for and against ID, yet his methods of inquiry pander to inflammatory tabloid antics more than a genuine inquiry of the films chosen, loaded subject matter. Rather than pondering the notion of a God or how the rise of Christian fundamentalism has affected the ID debate within the scientific community (the film interviews several professors of science blacklisted for merely giving ID the time of day in serious discussion), Stein goes for easy targets and exploitative arguments that make some of Michael Moore’s tactics look saintly by comparison. Without going into great detail, Expelled goes so far as to equate the lack of free speech in today’s scientific community (itself a sad reflection on the status quo) with the sum loss of life at the hands of the Nazi’s in WWII.
Frightening as this is, it says nothing of Stein’s already gut-churning lack of humility; for a film so appalled at a dearth of open-mindedness, Expelled never even grazes the age-old conundrum of “If God made us, then who made God?” The imposed slant of the film rarely eases its stranglehold – even the anti-ID voices interviewed therein often feel deliberately handpicked for their lack of charm or grace in discussion as Stein lays out his bullying verbal traps. There are many who believe that a union between spiritual and scientific exploration is needed to foster any true progress in either category. With the utterly inept Expelled, Stein does nothing short of shooting himself in the foot, considerably setting back any such understanding in the process. No intelligence, indeed.
Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed movie poster – Premise Media Corporation
Ben Stein in deep thought in Expelled – Premise Media Corporation


